Cartel (anti-competitive agreement)

Glossary category

What is a cartel?

A cartel is an agreement or coordinated practice between businesses that are, or could be, competitors and that has as its object or effect the restriction of competition. Cartels typically replace independent commercial decision-making with coordination on issues that should normally be determined by market conditions, such as prices, customers, territories, production volumes or participation in tenders.

Under Polish and EU competition law, a cartel may take the form of a written contract, an oral arrangement, a decision of an association of undertakings, an exchange of commercially sensitive information or coordinated conduct. It is not necessary for the parties to use the word “agreement” or create a formal document. Competition authorities may assess the actual conduct of the businesses, including meetings, correspondence, pricing patterns and information exchanges.

Cartel conduct is regarded as one of the most serious infringements of competition law. In Poland, such practices may be examined by the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK), while arrangements affecting trade between EU Member States may also fall within the scope of EU competition rules and be investigated by the European Commission or national competition authorities.


What does cartel conduct involve?

The most common forms of cartel activity include price fixing, market sharing, bid rigging, output limitation and customer allocation. Price fixing may involve agreeing on prices, discounts, margins, payment terms or future price increases. Market sharing can concern geographical areas, groups of customers, distribution channels or particular product categories.

Bid rigging occurs when participants in a tender coordinate their offers instead of competing independently. For example, businesses may agree which entity will submit the winning bid, submit deliberately unattractive offers, withdraw offers or rotate successful bidders. Such conduct may affect private procurement as well as public procurement procedures.

A cartel may also be created through the exchange of commercially sensitive market information. Sharing historic and aggregated data is not always prohibited. However, exchanging current or future information on prices, costs, volumes, customers, strategic plans or tender intentions may reduce uncertainty between competitors and facilitate unlawful coordination. The legal assessment depends on the nature of the information, the market structure, the purpose of the exchange and the circumstances in which it occurs.

Not every arrangement between businesses is a cartel. Certain forms of cooperation may be lawful where they are objectively necessary, proportionate and do not eliminate effective competition. This may concern, for example, some joint ventures, research and development projects, distribution arrangements or cooperation required for a specific transaction. Each arrangement should nevertheless be assessed individually under competition law.


When is legal assistance concerning a cartel needed?

Legal support may be necessary whenever a business cooperates with competitors, participates in industry associations, exchanges market information, takes part in tenders or receives communications that could suggest coordinated commercial conduct. Particular caution is required during trade association meetings, negotiations with competitors, benchmarking projects and joint responses to procurement opportunities.

Companies may also need assistance when they receive a request for information from UOKiK or the European Commission, face an inspection, identify suspicious internal correspondence or receive a report through a whistleblowing channel. Individuals involved in commercial decision-making may require separate advice because competition law infringements can expose both businesses and managers to significant legal and financial consequences.

A prompt consultation with a competition lawyer can help identify risks before they develop into an investigation or dispute. It may prevent the use of inappropriate communication practices, the disclosure of sensitive information, participation in unlawful meetings or errors in responding to an authority’s actions. Early legal assessment may also be relevant when a business considers reporting its involvement in a cartel under an applicable leniency framework.


Legal support in cartel and competition law matters

Law firm support in matters concerning cartels and anti-competitive agreements may include in particular:

  • assessing agreements, communications and commercial practices for compliance with competition law;
  • advising on contacts with competitors, trade associations and industry initiatives;
  • reviewing tender procedures and identifying bid-rigging risks;
  • preparing competition law compliance policies and internal procedures;
  • conducting internal reviews and supporting fact-finding activities;
  • assisting during inspections, requests for information and proceedings before UOKiK or EU authorities;
  • advising on leniency, settlement and corrective measures where potential infringements are identified;
  • representing businesses and managers in competition-related disputes and proceedings.


Need legal assistance regarding a suspected cartel or anti-competitive agreement? Contact us.


See also