What is abuse of a dominant position?
Abuse of a dominant position is a competition law infringement committed by an undertaking that holds a position of economic strength and uses that position in a way that restricts competition or exploits trading partners or consumers. A dominant position does not mean that a business is prohibited from being successful, having a large market share, or holding a strong position in its sector. Competition law intervenes only where that position is used improperly.
In the European Union, the principal legal basis is Article 102 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. In Poland, the prohibition is also regulated by the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. These rules apply where conduct may affect competition in Poland or trade between EU Member States, depending on the scope of the relevant market and the effects of the conduct.
A company may be regarded as dominant where it can act to an appreciable extent independently of competitors, customers and consumers. Market share is an important factor, but it is not the only one. Authorities also assess barriers to entry, the number and strength of competitors, customer dependence, access to key infrastructure, intellectual property rights, network effects and the company’s financial or technological advantage.
What conduct may constitute abuse of a dominant position?
Abuse may take different forms depending on the market, the business model and the company’s relationship with trading partners. The key issue is whether the conduct departs from competition on the merits and is capable of excluding competitors, limiting customer choice or harming consumers.
Examples of potentially abusive conduct include:
- imposing unfair purchase or selling prices, or other unfair contractual conditions;
- charging prices below relevant cost benchmarks in order to eliminate competitors;
- refusing to supply goods, services, data or access to essential infrastructure without objective justification;
- granting rebates or discounts that encourage customers to buy exclusively or predominantly from the dominant undertaking;
- tying the sale of one product or service to the purchase of another;
- applying dissimilar conditions to equivalent transactions with trading partners, thereby placing them at a competitive disadvantage;
- limiting production, markets, technical development or investment to the detriment of customers or consumers;
- using contractual restrictions to prevent customers or business partners from working with competitors.
Not every aggressive commercial practice is unlawful. A dominant undertaking may compete on price, quality, innovation and efficiency. It may also protect legitimate commercial interests. However, it has a special responsibility not to impair effective and undistorted competition in the market. Whether particular conduct is abusive requires an assessment of its economic and legal context.
When should a business seek legal advice?
Legal advice may be important before implementing pricing policies, exclusivity arrangements, loyalty schemes, distribution systems, refusals to deal or changes to access conditions for key products, platforms or infrastructure. This is particularly relevant for businesses with a high market share, control over scarce resources, operating a leading digital platform, or a strong position in local or specialist markets.
Entrepreneurs should also seek support when a competitor, supplier, customer or regulator alleges abuse of dominance. Such allegations may arise in disputes concerning pricing, supply conditions, access to distribution channels, tender procedures, licensing terms or the operation of online marketplaces. Early analysis can help determine whether the company holds a dominant position, define the relevant market and identify objective justifications for the challenged conduct.
For smaller businesses, legal support may be necessary where they suspect that a stronger trading partner is using its market power to impose unfair terms, restrict access to the market or discriminate between customers. Competition law remedies may include intervention by the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection, civil claims or interim measures, depending on the circumstances of the case.
A prompt consultation with a competition lawyer can help avoid poorly designed commercial practices, regulatory investigations, disputes with trading partners, financial penalties and reputational consequences. It can also assist in documenting the commercial rationale for a business decision and introducing safeguards before an agreement or pricing model is implemented.
Law firm support in abuse of dominance matters includes in particular:
- assessing whether an undertaking may hold a dominant position in a relevant market;
- reviewing pricing, rebate, discount, exclusivity and distribution arrangements;
- analysing refusals to supply, access restrictions and discriminatory trading conditions;
- preparing competition law compliance procedures and internal guidance;
- supporting businesses during proceedings before the President of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection;
- representing clients in disputes related to anti-competitive conduct;
- advising on contractual solutions that reduce competition law risks.
Need legal assistance with an abuse of dominant position issue? Contact us.